BENCH: Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and
Justice Kshitij Shailendra
FACTS:
The petitioner, an
Advocate practising in the District Court, Bulandshahr, filed a writ petition
in the nature of Public Interest Litigation challenging the elections of the
Executive Body of the Civil Bar Association, Bulandshahr, held for the year
2025–26. The elections were notified on 04.04.2026 pursuant to a meeting held
on 28.03.2026 and were conducted on 16.04.2026. The petitioner contended that
the election was contrary to the directions issued by the Supreme Court in Deeksha
N. Amruthesh v. State of Karnataka, particularly the direction requiring at
least 30% representation of women advocates in the governing or executive
bodies of Bar Associations. Although the voter list contained 79 women members,
comprising 65 ordinary members and 14 life members, no woman had been elected
as an office bearer in the election.
During the
proceedings, the respondents submitted that four women advocates had
subsequently been nominated by the elected body, one as Joint Treasurer and
three as Executive Members and had assumed office. The petitioner challenged
these nominations on the ground that the post of Joint Treasurer did not exist
and that the nominations were made contrary to the Supreme Court’s directions.
The respondents contended that the Supreme Court’s order dated 13.03.2026 had
been communicated to them only on 08.04.2026, after the election process had
already commenced. They further relied on the Supreme Court’s subsequent order
dated 16.04.2026, which permitted the shortfall in women’s representation to be
addressed through nominations where women advocates had not contested. The High
Court therefore examined the effect of the Supreme Court’s directions of
13.03.2026 and 16.04.2026 and the validity of the subsequent nominations.
ISSUES:
The principal issues before the Court were
whether the elections of the Civil Bar Association, Bulandshahr, held on
16.04.2026, were contrary to the Supreme Court’s directions requiring 30%
representation of women advocates; whether the subsequent nomination of four
women advocates could satisfy the requirement despite being made over and above
the originally elected strength of the executive body; whether the nominations
were invalid because they were not made by the Administrative or Portfolio
Judge in consultation with the authorities and members specified in the Supreme
Court’s order dated 16.04.2026; and whether these procedural defects warranted
quashing the entire election and directing fresh elections.
JUDGEMENT WITH REASONING:
The High Court disposed of the writ
petition without quashing the elections or the subsequent nominations. It held
that although the Bar Association had initially failed to provide 30%
representation to women advocates among the 12 elected office bearers, the
subsequent nomination of four women advocates, made within four days of the
election, fulfilled the substantive requirement of 30% representation in the
circumstances of the case. However, the Court found that the manner in which
the nominations were made did not comply with the procedure prescribed by the
Supreme Court’s order dated 16.04.2026. The elected body was therefore directed
to amend its bye-laws within one month to provide for 30% representation of
women advocates in all future elections and to place the details of the
nominations and election proceedings before the Administrative Judge of
District Bulandshahr for consideration in accordance with the Supreme Court’s
directions. Until otherwise ordered, the election and nominations were
permitted to remain intact.
The Court first
examined the sequence of directions issued by the Supreme Court in Deeksha
N. Amruthesh v. State of Karnataka. It noted that the earlier directions
concerning 30% representation had initially applied to Bar Associations in
Karnataka, but the Supreme Court’s order dated 13.03.2026 extended the
requirement to Bar Associations across the country. The Court held that the
respondents could not rely on their assertion that they became aware of the
order only on 08.04.2026, because the order had already become operative when
the election programme was notified on 04.04.2026 and was publicly available.
Consequently, the Bar Association ought to have taken the Supreme Court’s
directions into account while conducting the election. The High Court therefore
found that the initial failure to provide 30% representation among the 12
elected office-bearer posts was not in accordance with the directions then in
force. However, the Supreme Court itself modified and clarified the mechanism
for securing representation through its order dated 16.04.2026. Since no woman
advocate had come forward to contest the election, the provision permitting the
shortfall to be addressed through nominations became applicable.
The Court then
considered the effect of the four nominations made on 20.04.2026. It found that
the nominations were procedurally defective because they had been made solely
by the elected office bearers, whereas the Supreme Court had directed that
nominations be made by the Administrative Judge/Portfolio Judge of the
jurisdictional High Court in consultation with the District and Sessions Judge,
elected office bearers and the senior-most women members of the concerned Bar
Association. Nevertheless, the Court found that the nominations could not be
treated as wholly illegal because the Supreme Court’s order expressly
contemplated nominations where women advocates did not contest, and the four
nominations were made promptly after the election. With 12 elected members and
four nominated women advocates, the total strength became 16, and the Court
considered that the inclusion of four women advocates substantially fulfilled
the intended 30% representation. It therefore concluded that setting aside the
entire election would serve no meaningful purpose, particularly when the
substantive objective of representation had already been achieved. Instead, the
Court granted the Bar Association time to regularise its position by amending
its bye-laws and directed compliance with the procedure prescribed by the
Supreme Court for the future.
ANALYSIS:
The decision
demonstrates the Court’s attempt to balance strict compliance with the Supreme
Court’s mandate on women’s representation in Bar Associations with the need to
avoid unnecessarily disrupting an election that had already taken place. The
High Court found that the Civil Bar Association was required to comply with the
Supreme Court’s direction extending the requirement of 30% representation of
women advocates to Bar Associations across the country. The Court did not
accept the contention that the respondents could avoid compliance merely
because they claimed to have received the Supreme Court’s order only after the
election process had commenced, particularly since the order had already been
passed before the election notification. Thus, the initial election, in which
none of the 12 elected office bearers was a woman, did not satisfy the
prescribed requirement. At the same time, the subsequent order of the Supreme
Court dated 16.04.2026 provided a mechanism for addressing the shortfall
through nominations where women advocates had not contested the election. The
High Court therefore considered the subsequent nominations while determining
whether the substantive requirement had ultimately been fulfilled.
The Court nevertheless
identified a procedural defect in the manner in which the four women advocates
were nominated. The nominations had been made by the elected office bearers
themselves, whereas the Supreme Court had contemplated nominations through the
Administrative or Portfolio Judge in consultation with the specified judicial
and Bar Association authorities. Despite this defect, the High Court did not
consider it necessary to invalidate the entire election because four women
advocates had been nominated shortly after the election, thereby bringing the
total executive strength to 16 and providing the required level of
representation. The decision therefore distinguishes between substantive
compliance with the objective of women’s representation and procedural
compliance with the mechanism prescribed for achieving it. Rather than
nullifying the election, the Court directed the Bar Association to amend its
bye-laws to incorporate the 30% representation requirement for future elections
and to place the relevant election and nomination details before the
Administrative Judge for consideration in accordance with the Supreme Court’s
directions.