BENCH: Chief Justice Dr. Dhananjaya Y.
Chandrachud and Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Sanjiv Khanna, B. R. Gavai, and
Surya Kant
FACTS:
The dispute concerning
Article 370 of the Constitution arose from the special constitutional status
accorded to the erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir following its accession to
India in 1947. Article 370, incorporated into the Constitution of India, provided
a framework governing the application of the Indian Constitution and the
extension of legislative powers of Parliament to Jammu and Kashmir. Over the
years, various constitutional orders were issued to extend provisions of the
Indian Constitution to the State. On 5 August 2019, the President of India
issued Constitution Order C.O. 272, applying all provisions of the Indian
Constitution to Jammu and Kashmir and modifying the manner in which Article 370
was to operate. Subsequently, Parliament adopted a resolution recommending that
Article 370 cease to operate, and the President issued Constitution Order C.O.
273 on 6 August 2019, declaring that all clauses of Article 370 would cease to
operate except a modified clause stating that the Indian Constitution applied
in its entirety to Jammu and Kashmir.
The same day,
Parliament recommended the cessation of Article 370, and on 6 August 2019, the
President issued Constitution Order C.O. 273, giving effect to the decision.
Parliament subsequently enacted the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019,
providing for the bifurcation of the erstwhile State into the Union Territories
of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh. These measures were challenged before the
Supreme Court by several petitioners, who questioned their constitutional
validity, particularly the use of Article 367 to alter the meaning of
references to the Constituent Assembly in Article 370, the exercise of
Parliament’s powers during President’s Rule, and the authority to render
Article 370 inoperative without the recommendation of the dissolved Constituent
Assembly. The petitions were referred to a five-judge Constitution Bench, which
commenced hearing the matter on 2 August 2023.
ISSUES:
The principal issues
before the Supreme Court were whether Article 370 was a temporary provision or
had acquired permanence; whether Constitution Order C.O. 272, particularly its
amendment to Article 367 substituting the reference to the Constituent Assembly
of Jammu and Kashmir with the Legislative Assembly, was constitutionally valid;
whether the entire Constitution of India could be extended to Jammu and Kashmir
under Article 370(1)(d); whether Article 370 could be rendered inoperative
without the recommendation of the dissolved Constituent Assembly; whether the
exercise of powers during President’s Rule and the dissolution of the State
Legislative Assembly were constitutionally valid; and whether the reorganisation
of Jammu and Kashmir into Union Territories, including Ladakh, was lawful.
JUDGEMENT WITH REASONING:
On 11 December 2023, a
unanimous five-judge Constitution Bench upheld the constitutional validity of
the effective abrogation of Article 370. The Court held that Article 370 was a
temporary provision, that Jammu and Kashmir did not retain any internal sovereignty
after its accession to India, and that the President had the power to declare
Article 370 inoperative. Although the Court invalidated the modification to
Article 367 that substituted the Legislative Assembly for the Constituent
Assembly, it upheld the application of the entire Constitution of India to
Jammu and Kashmir and the declaration rendering Article 370 inoperative. The
Court also upheld the creation of the Union Territory of Ladakh, while leaving
the broader question concerning the conversion of a State into Union
Territories unresolved in light of the Union Government’s undertaking to
restore statehood to Jammu and Kashmir.
The Court reasoned
that Jammu and Kashmir did not possess any separate or residual sovereignty
after its accession to India and the adoption of the Constitution of India. It
relied on Article 1 of the Indian Constitution, which declares India to be a
Union of States, and the constitutional history of Jammu and Kashmir, including
the Instrument of Accession and the proclamation adopting the Indian
Constitution. The Court observed that Article 370 represented a form of
asymmetric federalism intended to accommodate the circumstances prevailing at
the time of accession, rather than an arrangement conferring independent
sovereignty upon the State. It further held that Article 370 was temporary in
nature and that the dissolution of the Jammu and Kashmir Constituent Assembly
in 1957 did not extinguish the President’s power under Article 370(3). The
requirement for the Constituent Assembly’s recommendation under the proviso to
Article 370(3) ceased to operate upon the dissolution of that Assembly, and its
absence did not permanently prevent the President from exercising the power to
declare Article 370 inoperative.
The Court further held
that the President could exercise the power under Article 370(1)(d) to apply
all provisions of the Indian Constitution to Jammu and Kashmir, including
without the concurrence of the State Government, as the constitutional
framework permitted such application. However, the President could not use
Article 367, which deals with interpretation, to alter the meaning of Article
370 by substituting the Legislative Assembly for the Constituent Assembly; that
interpretative modification was therefore invalid. Nevertheless, the invalidity
of this part of C.O. 272 did not invalidate the application of the entire
Constitution or the subsequent C.O. 273, which rendered Article 370
inoperative. On the issue of President’s Rule, the Court applied the principles
governing judicial review under Article 356, holding that the exercise of power
must be examined for mala fides or palpably irrational action rather than
invalidated merely because it involved the exercise of powers ordinarily
belonging to the State Legislature. Regarding reorganisation, the Court upheld
the creation of Ladakh as a Union Territory and, in view of the Union
Government’s undertaking to restore statehood to Jammu and Kashmir, did not
finally determine the validity of converting the entire State into Union Territories.
ANALYSIS:
The Supreme Court’s
decision in In Re: Article 370 of the Constitution, 2023 INSC 1058, represents
a significant interpretation of the constitutional relationship between the
Union of India and Jammu and Kashmir. By holding that Article 370 was a temporary
provision and that Jammu and Kashmir did not retain separate internal
sovereignty, the Court emphasised the constitutional integration of the
erstwhile State within the Indian Union. Its interpretation of Article 370(3)
established that the dissolution of the Constituent Assembly in 1957 did not
permanently restrict the President’s power to declare the provision
inoperative. The judgment also distinguished between the constitutional
validity of applying the entire Constitution of India to Jammu and Kashmir and
the impermissibility of using Article 367 to modify the meaning of Article 370.
This distinction demonstrated the Court’s approach of examining the legality of
individual constitutional measures separately rather than treating the entire
process as invalid merely because one component was unconstitutional.
The judgment also
raises important questions concerning federalism, the exercise of executive
power during President’s Rule, and the constitutional safeguards governing the
reorganisation of States. Although the Court upheld the effective abrogation of
Article 370 and the creation of Ladakh as a Union Territory, its decision to
leave the broader question concerning the conversion of Jammu and Kashmir into
Union Territories unresolved, in light of the Union Government’s undertaking to
restore statehood, leaves an important aspect of federal restructuring subject
to further constitutional developments. The ruling reinforces the principle
that constitutional powers must be exercised within the limits prescribed by
the Constitution, even when the objective is national integration. At the same
time, it highlights the tension between the Union’s authority to alter
constitutional arrangements and the federal principle that States should retain
meaningful constitutional status and democratic representation. Consequently,
the judgment is important not only for determining the status of Article 370
but also for its implications for constitutional interpretation, federal
governance, and the scope of judicial review over major political and
constitutional decisions.