BENCH: Justice S.P. Bharucha, Justice S.S.M. Quadri and Justice M.B. Shah
FACTS:
The dispute arose when
the husband, Aresh Satya Goel, instituted divorce proceedings against his wife,
Mona Aresh Goel, before the Family Court at Bandra, Bombay, in M.J. Petition
No. A-636 of 1999. At the time of filing the transfer petition before the Supreme
Court, the wife was residing with her parents in Delhi. She sought the transfer
of the pending divorce proceedings from Bombay to Delhi, contending that she
had no independent source of income and was unable to bear the expenses of
travelling from Delhi to Bombay to contest the case.
The wife further
submitted that her parents were not financially capable of meeting her travel
expenses and that, being only twenty-two years old, she could neither travel to
Bombay nor stay there alone, as she had no one in the city with whom she could reside.
She therefore approached the Supreme Court seeking the transfer of the
matrimonial proceedings to a competent court in Delhi, where she was living
with her parents. The respondent-husband was served with notice of the transfer
petition but did not appear before the Supreme Court.
ISSUES:
The principal issue
was whether the divorce proceedings instituted by the husband before the Family
Court at Bandra, Bombay, should be transferred to a competent court in Delhi,
considering the wife’s lack of independent income, her parents’ inability to
bear her travel expenses, her young age, and her inability to travel to and
stay in Bombay without assistance.
JUDGEMENT WITH REASONING:
The Supreme Court
allowed the wife’s transfer petition and ordered that M.J. Petition No. A-636
of 1999, pending before the Family Court at Bandra, Bombay, be transferred to
the Court of the District Judge, Tis Hazari, Delhi. The District Judge was
directed to hear the matter or assign it to a competent court. No order was
made as to costs.
The Supreme Court
considered the specific financial and personal difficulties pleaded by the wife
in seeking the transfer of the matrimonial proceedings. She was residing with
her parents in Delhi and had no independent source of income to meet the expenses
of travelling to Bombay to contest the divorce petition. Her parents were also
unable to bear these expenses. Requiring her to travel between Delhi and Bombay
to participate in the proceedings would therefore impose a substantial
financial burden on her and create practical difficulties in effectively
defending herself in the matrimonial litigation. The Court considered these
circumstances sufficient to justify transferring the proceedings to Delhi,
where she was residing.
The Court also took
into account the wife’s age of twenty-two years and her assertion that she
could neither travel to nor stay in Bombay alone because she had no one there
with whom she could reside. These circumstances strengthened her claim that
continuing the proceedings in Bombay would cause her considerable hardship. The
respondent-husband, despite having been served with notice, did not appear
before the Supreme Court to oppose the transfer petition. Having considered the
averments made in the petition and the absence of any opposition, the Court
concluded that the transfer should be allowed in the circumstances of the case.
Accordingly, it directed the transfer of the divorce proceedings to Delhi,
thereby enabling the wife to participate in the litigation without the
difficulties associated with travelling to and staying in Bombay.
ANALYSIS:
The decision in Mona
Aresh Goel v. Aresh Satya Goel (2000) 9 SCC 255 highlights the importance of
considering the practical difficulties faced by a party when determining
whether matrimonial proceedings should be transferred from one court to
another. The Supreme Court recognised that the wife’s lack of independent
income, her parents’ financial inability to support her travel, and her
inability to travel to or reside in Bombay without assistance constituted
genuine hardships. Requiring her to contest the proceedings in a distant forum
would have imposed a considerable burden on her and potentially hindered her
effective participation in the litigation. The decision reflects the Court’s
exercise of its transfer jurisdiction to ensure that procedural requirements do
not impose undue hardship on a litigant seeking access to justice.
The case also
demonstrates the significance of the individual circumstances of the parties in
deciding transfer petitions involving matrimonial disputes. The wife’s young
age, her residence with her parents in Delhi, and the absence of anyone with
whom she could stay in Bombay were relevant considerations in assessing the
inconvenience associated with continuing the proceedings at the original forum.
Furthermore, the husband’s failure to appear despite being served with notice
meant that the transfer petition remained unopposed. By directing the transfer
of the divorce proceedings to Delhi, the Supreme Court adopted a practical
approach intended to facilitate the wife’s participation in the litigation. The
decision illustrates that the convenience of the parties, their financial
circumstances, and the interests of justice are important considerations when
determining the appropriate forum for matrimonial proceedings.