BENCH: Justice Dr. Dhananjaya Y.
Chandrachud and Justice M. R. Shah
FACTS:
The case arose from an
incident that occurred on 13 March 2015, when the then Finance Minister of
Kerala was presenting the State Budget for the financial year 2015–2016 in the
Kerala Legislative Assembly. Six opposition Members of the Legislative Assembly
disrupted the budget presentation, climbed onto the Speaker’s dais and damaged
furniture and equipment, including the Speaker’s chair, computer, microphone,
emergency lamp and electronic panel, causing an estimated loss of ₹2,20,093.
Following a complaint lodged by the Legislative Secretary, the Museum Police
Station registered Crime No. 236 of 2015 under Sections 447 and 427 read with
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and Section 3(1) of the Prevention
of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984. After investigation, a final report was
submitted, and the case proceeded before the criminal court.
Subsequently, the
State Government decided to withdraw the prosecution against the six accused
legislators, and the Public Prosecutor sought the court’s permission under
Section 321 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram, declined to grant permission for withdrawal of
the prosecution. The matter was challenged before the Kerala High Court, which,
by its judgment dated 12 March 2021, upheld the Magistrate’s order in the
exercise of its revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure. Aggrieved by the High Court’s decision, the State of Kerala
approached the Supreme Court by filing a petition for special leave to appeal.
The accused legislators also filed a separate petition challenging the High
Court’s order, bringing the dispute before the Supreme Court for consideration.
ISSUES:
The principal issues
before the Supreme Court were whether the Public Prosecutor was justified in
seeking withdrawal of the criminal prosecution against six legislators under
Section 321 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and whether the Chief Judicial
Magistrate had correctly refused consent for such withdrawal. The Court also
considered whether the legislators could claim immunity from criminal
prosecution under Article 194 of the Constitution for acts of vandalism
committed within the Legislative Assembly, whether the Speaker’s sanction was
necessary before initiating criminal proceedings, and whether video recordings
of the Assembly proceedings could be relied upon as evidence.
JUDGEMENT WITH REASONING:
On 28 July 2021, the
Supreme Court dismissed the appeals filed by the State of Kerala and the
accused legislators, thereby upholding the refusal to permit withdrawal of the
prosecution. The Court held that legislative privileges and immunities under
Article 194 do not provide protection against criminal liability for acts of
vandalism that are not connected with the legitimate discharge of legislative
functions. It further held that the Public Prosecutor’s request under Section
321 CrPC must serve the broader interests of public justice and cannot be
granted merely on the grounds of political considerations or legislative
privilege.
The Court reasoned
that Section 321 CrPC entrusts the Public Prosecutor with the responsibility of
independently deciding whether withdrawal from prosecution is justified,
subject to the consent of the court. Although the Public Prosecutor may seek
withdrawal for reasons extending beyond insufficient evidence, the decision
must be guided by the broader objectives of public justice and the proper
administration of criminal law. The court’s role is supervisory but judicial in
nature, requiring it to examine whether the prosecutor has applied an
independent mind, whether relevant considerations support the withdrawal, and
whether granting consent would interfere with the normal course of justice for
illegitimate purposes. In the present case, the prosecution concerned
allegations of deliberate damage to public property inside the Legislative
Assembly, for which a final report had been filed following investigation. The
Court found that permitting withdrawal in these circumstances would undermine
the administration of justice, particularly when the allegations involved
conduct that was not necessary for the performance of legislative duties. It
therefore concluded that the Chief Judicial Magistrate had validly refused
consent for withdrawal of the prosecution.
The Court further held
that the privileges conferred on legislators under Article 194 are functional
in nature and exist to enable members to discharge their legislative
responsibilities freely, without fear or improper interference. Such privileges
are not personal immunities that place elected representatives above the
ordinary criminal law applicable to other citizens. The alleged destruction of
furniture and equipment during the budget presentation could not be regarded as
an act necessary for effective participation in legislative proceedings and, consequently,
could not be protected by legislative privilege. The Court also rejected the
proposition that the Speaker’s prior sanction was required before criminal
proceedings could be initiated against the legislators, as no such general
requirement arose from the Constitution or the applicable rules of the
Assembly. Further, the Court considered the objection concerning the use of
video recordings of the incident and examined the constitutional distinction
between the freedom of legislative proceedings and immunity from criminal
accountability. It emphasised that constitutional privileges cannot be invoked
to obstruct a legitimate criminal investigation or to shield conduct amounting
to offences against public property. Accordingly, the Court concluded that
allowing the prosecution to continue was consistent with the rule of law,
equality before the law, and the principle that legislative privilege must
remain confined to its constitutionally intended purpose.
ANALYSIS:
The Supreme Court’s
decision in The State of Kerala v. K. Ajith, 2021 INSC 366, is significant for
clarifying the limits of legislative privilege and reinforcing the principle
that elected representatives are not above the ordinary criminal law. By holding
that Article 194 of the Constitution does not grant immunity for acts of
vandalism unrelated to the legitimate discharge of legislative functions, the
Court distinguished between protecting legislators’ freedom of speech and
action within the House and shielding them from criminal accountability for
unlawful conduct. The judgment emphasised that legislative privileges are
constitutional safeguards intended to ensure the effective functioning of
democratic institutions, rather than personal privileges that can be invoked to
escape legal consequences. It also reaffirmed the importance of Section 321 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, by underscoring that withdrawal from
prosecution must be guided by public justice and cannot be justified solely by
political considerations or the status of the accused.
The judgment further
strengthens judicial oversight of prosecutorial discretion by establishing that
a court must independently assess whether a request to withdraw a prosecution
is based on legitimate grounds and serves the interests of justice. Although
the Public Prosecutor has discretion to seek withdrawal, that discretion is
neither absolute nor immune from judicial scrutiny. The refusal to permit
withdrawal in this case reflects the Court’s concern that politically motivated
decisions should not undermine accountability for damage to public property. At
a broader constitutional level, the ruling reinforces the rule of law, equality
before the law and the accountability of public officials, including elected
legislators. It also highlights the delicate balance between legislative
autonomy and judicial authority: while legislative proceedings deserve
constitutional protection from undue interference, that protection cannot
extend to conduct that falls outside the legitimate exercise of legislative
functions. Consequently, the decision serves as an important precedent on the
limits of legislative immunity and the responsibility of constitutional
institutions to uphold public accountability and the administration of criminal
justice.