The Gujarat High Court has dismissed an appeal filed by Aam
Aadmi Party convenor Arvind Kejriwal against an earlier single-judge order that
had set aside a Central Information Commission directive requiring Gujarat
University to disclose details of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s academic
degree. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Sunita Agarwal and Justice
D.N. Ray found no reason to interfere with the single judge’s decision, which
had both quashed the 2016 CIC order and imposed a cost of ₹25,000 on Kejriwal.
The Bench concluded that none of the arguments advanced on behalf of the
appellant disclosed any error in the impugned judgment and accordingly
dismissed the appeal without awarding any further costs.
The single-judge Bench had, on 31 March 2023, not only
nullified the CIC’s direction but also reprimanded Kejriwal for what it
regarded as a casual and improper use of the Right to Information Act. During
the hearing of the appeal, senior counsel Abhishek Manu Singhvi, appearing for
Kejriwal, contested the imposition of costs. He argued that his client had not
persistently pursued the matter in the manner suggested by the single judge.
According to the counsel, the CIC had initiated the proceedings suo motu on the
basis of a letter rather than a formal RTI application, and Kejriwal had merely
been named as a respondent. The lawyers further pointed out that although
Gujarat University had claimed before the single judge that the degree was
already available online, the document had in fact never been placed in the
public domain, an assertion that was rejected when Kejriwal sought a review of
the single-judge order.
Counsel for Kejriwal also submitted that if the degree had
indeed been made available online by the University on account of its public
importance, it would fall within the scope of the RTI Act and the cause of
action would cease to exist. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing
Gujarat University, strongly opposed the appeal. He contended that Kejriwal had
pursued the litigation relentlessly and had even held press conferences that
tended to defame the institution. The Solicitor General urged the Court to
uphold the costs so as to discourage misuse of the RTI Act and to prevent
government officials from being compelled to expend productive time on requests
that did not serve the statute’s genuine purpose.
The controversy originated in 2016 when Kejriwal wrote to
the CIC seeking public disclosure of the Prime Minister’s educational
qualifications. In April that year, then Information Commissioner M. Sridhar
Acharyulu directed both Delhi University and Gujarat University to furnish the
relevant records to Kejriwal. The order was passed a day after Kejriwal
informed the Commission that he had no objection to government records about
himself being made public and questioned why information concerning the Prime
Minister’s degrees was being withheld. Gujarat University challenged the CIC
directive before the High Court, which stayed the order. In May 2016 the then
Vice-Chancellor of Gujarat University publicly stated that Narendra Modi had
obtained a Master of Arts degree in Political Science in 1983 as an external
student, securing 62.3 per cent marks. The University simultaneously uploaded
the degree on its website and pursued its writ petition. The single judge
ultimately quashed the CIC order, criticised the Commission for engaging in
judicial activism, and imposed the ₹25,000 cost on Kejriwal. It was this
decision that Kejriwal carried in appeal before the Division Bench, which has
now affirmed the single judge’s conclusions in their entirety.